The Most Trusted Voice in Dot-Com Criticism

Notion

Productivity | Reviewed by Tia Jolentino | January 11, 2026
5.6
Site Information
Name: Notion
Founded: 2016
Type: All-in-One Workspace
VERDICT: A productivity platform that's successfully convinced millions of people to pay for the privilege of turning their jobs into elaborate spreadsheets, now with AI to automate the existential crisis.

I've been watching Notion evolve from a scrappy note-taking app beloved by productivity Twitter into this omnipresent workplace behemoth, and there's something deeply unsettling about how it now promises to eliminate "busywork" through AI agents that learn "how you work." The tagline "One workspace. Zero busywork" feels like late-stage capitalism's fever dream—as if the problem with modern work isn't its fundamental meaninglessness, but simply that we haven't automated enough of our humanity away. I keep thinking about how my friend spent three months building the "perfect" Notion workspace for her startup, color-coding databases and creating templates, only to abandon it when she realized she was spending more time organizing her work than actually doing it. Now Notion wants to solve this by adding an AI layer that promises to do our thinking for us, which feels like admitting defeat while simultaneously doubling down.

The website's design embodies that particular Silicon Valley aesthetic that mistakes minimalism for profundity—lots of white space punctuated by sans-serif declarations about productivity optimization. There's something almost religious about how they present their "Agent" feature, complete with arrow graphics suggesting divine intervention in your workflow. The copy reads like it was written by someone who has never experienced the specific agony of being asked to "sync up" about "action items" in a "collaborative space." When they say "Your Agent learns how you work," I want to ask: what if how I work is badly, frantically, and with tremendous amounts of procrastination? Will the AI learn to spend two hours researching font choices for a presentation due in twenty minutes, or will it deprive me of even these small acts of self-sabotage that make me feel human?

The pricing structure remains mysteriously absent from the main messaging, replaced instead with a "Calculate savings below" prompt that feels like a trap designed to make you justify subscription costs you haven't seen yet. This is the Notion playbook: seduce you with the promise of organizational nirvana, then gradually reveal the monthly fees required to maintain your digital workspace monastery. The "Bring all your tools and teams under one roof" pitch assumes that consolidation equals efficiency, when anyone who has worked in a modern office knows that tools multiply like rabbits specifically because no single platform can actually do everything well. It's the Swiss Army knife fallacy—technically impressive, practically mediocre at each individual function.

What disturbs me most is how Notion positions itself as solving problems it helped create. The explosion of "productivity culture" that treats human attention like a resource to be optimized has created an entire generation of workers who believe their worth is measured by their ability to systematize spontaneity. The promise that an AI agent can handle your "busywork" while you focus on "meaningful tasks" ignores the reality that most jobs under capitalism consist primarily of busywork with occasional moments of meaning scattered throughout like raisins in terrible cereal. The website's testimonials and use cases read like productivity porn—fantasy scenarios where organized databases lead to professional fulfillment rather than just more sophisticated ways to document your alienation.

Ultimately, Notion represents the gamification of labor dressed up as liberation from labor. The platform succeeds not because it makes work more efficient, but because it makes work feel more like a video game, complete with progress bars, achievement systems, and the illusion of control over chaotic systems. The AI features feel like the logical endpoint of this trajectory—why stop at gamifying your own productivity when you can outsource it entirely to an algorithm trained on other people's optimization strategies? There's something deeply melancholy about a tool that promises to learn "how you work" in a world where most of us are still figuring out why we work at all.